That “mountain fresh” smell from a warm laundry basket is one of the little things of a comfortable life. For decades we’ve been told that fabric softeners and dryer sheets are the secret to soft, lint-free clothes. However, underneath that floral scent is a chemical compound that science suggests may be doing more harm than good, not just to your clothes, but to your health.
If you’ve ever noticed that your towels shrink or your skin feels itchy after a fresh shower, you’ve already seen the negative effects of these products. Here’s a look at the chemicals in fabric softeners, why their ingredients are cause for concern, and how you can get that same softness using natural alternatives.
How Fabric Softener Really Works
Image credit: Shutterstock
To understand why fabric softener is a problem, you must first understand what it actually does. Despite the name, it does not “soften” the fibers of your clothes by making them high quality. Rather, it dresses them.
During the wash cycle, laundry detergent, which is anionic, or negatively charged, removes dirt. Fabric softeners contain cationic surfactants, which carry a positive charge. Because opposites attract, these chemicals are positively charged”stick” on the negatively charged surface of your clothes, it forms a thin, waxy layer that makes the fibers stand up and slide past each other more easily. This reduces friction, makes things feel softer, and reduces electrical charge, eliminating static. Basically, fabric softener is like a heavy-duty hair conditioner on your clothes; it stays on the fabric long after the wash cycle.
Hidden Danger: Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs)
One of the biggest health concerns about fabric softeners is the release of Volatile Organic Compounds, or VOCs. VOCs are gases emitted from solid or liquid materials that can have short- and long-term health effects.
When you use a scented conditioner or dryer sheet, those “odorous” chemicals are released into the air by using the dryer and the clothes you wear. According to the Environmental Working Group (EWG) and various air quality studies, laundry facilities can emit harmful VOCs such as acetaldehyde and benzene, which are classified as carcinogens. Internally, these combinations can create “sick building syndrome,” leading to headaches, dizziness, and respiratory irritation in anyone who breathes the air.
Problematic Ingredients
Traditional sweeteners are a complex mixture of chemicals. Here are the most common formulas available:
1. Quaternary Ammonium Compounds (“Aquats”)
These are the first softening agents. They provide a smooth, lubricated feel and stop sticking. Quats are known to irritate the skin as well “asthmagens,” which means they can cause asthma in otherwise healthy people. Because they are designed to stay on fabric, they are constantly in contact with your skin, which can lead to contact dermatitis or chronic respiratory problems.
2. Fragrance and Phthalates
“Smell” is a legal loophole that allows companies to hide hundreds of individual chemicals under one name. Phthalates are often used in these fragrances to make the scent last longer on your clothes. Phthalates are notorious endocrine disruptors. They mimic hormones in the body and have been linked to fertility problems, developmental delays in children, and hormonal imbalances. Even the “unscented” versions often contain fragrances to mask the smell of the chemical base.
3. Antibiotics (such as Methylisothiazolinone)
Image credit: Shutterstock
Because liquid conditioners contain water, they require anti-fungal agents in the bottle. These preservatives are powerful allergens. They are one of the most common causes of skin rashes associated with washing and have been banned in some countries from use in “synthetic” cosmetic products because they are highly irritating to human tissue.
4. Artificial Dyes
Image credit: Shutterstock
Dyes are only positive, which makes this liquid signature as blue or pink. Like fragrance, synthetic dyes are often found in petroleum or coal tar and are unnecessary skin irritants that offer no functional benefit to the cleaning process.
Read more: Is Detergent Poisonous? 7 Questionable Ingredients You Should Look Out For
Environmental Threat
Besides the dangers to personal health, fabric softeners are a serious threat to our planet’s biological systems. Most conventional lubricants are petroleum-based, meaning they are derived from non-renewable fossil fuels and do not break down as easily once they are run down the drain. As these chemicals enter our waterways, they introduce potentially toxic substances such as glutaraldehyde and quats into the aquatic environment, which can be harmful to marine life and disrupt the delicate balance of river and ocean ecosystems. In addition, the waxy coating left by fabric softeners actually traps microplastics (small synthetic fibers that dissolve in polyester and nylon), preventing them from being filtered out and ultimately allowing them to pass through wastewater treatment facilities. Even the air is not safe; VOCs emitted from dryer vents contribute to ozone and low-level smog, making fabric softeners the rare household product that can contaminate water, soil, and air all at once.
Natural Alternatives That Really Work
Image credit: Shutterstock
The good news is that you don’t need a lab-created adhesive to have soft clothes. You probably already have some great alternatives in your pantry. Try these fabric softeners the next time you want your clothes to come out fresh and soft:
- Pure White Vinegar: This is the gold standard for natural moisturizers. Add ¼ to ½ cup to your fabric softener. Vinegar acid breaks down minerals in hard water and removes excess detergent residue. These are the two main reasons clothes feel “tight”. Don’t worry, the smell of vinegar disappears completely when the clothes are dry.
- Wool dryer balls: Instead of covering your clothes with wax, wool dryer balls work mechanically. As they fall, they jump between the layers of clothing, the air circulates, and “flips” through the threads. They can reduce drying time by up to 25% and are naturally hypoallergenic.
- Baking soda: Adding ½ cup of baking soda to the wash cycle helps regulate the pH level of the water. This prevents the “stiffness” caused by the detergent and leaves the clothes feeling soft and smelling neutral.
- Epsom Salts: For a DIY scented balm, mix 2 cups of Epsom salt with 20 drops of an essential oil, such as lavender or lemon. Add two tablespoons to the cleaning cycle. Minerals help to “loosen” the fibers of the fabric.
The Bottom Line
Fabric softeners are a prime example of a product that solves small problems while creating a big health and environmental impact. By coating our clothes with quats and phthalates, we trade skin and respiratory health for a fleeting floral scent.
By switching to other simple, time-tested methods such as vinegar balls and dryers, you can achieve the same results – soft, static-free laundry – without the chemical cocktail. Your skin, your lungs, and your wardrobe (which will last longer without this waxy build-up) will thank you.
Read more: The Safest Detergents: A Simple Guide to Non-Toxic, Eco-Friendly Laundry
